Home

/

Compare Dog Breeds

/

Working Kelpie vs Barbet

Working Kelpie vs Barbet

A close up of a black and tan Australian Kelpie with erect ears and a purple collar
Working Kelpie

Athletic, Intelligent, Energetic

A small fluffy brown dog with curly fur and a harness sits looking forward with its tongue out
Barbet

Intelligent, Energetic, Protective

VS

Characteristics

Barking

Quiet

Loud

Temperament with Kids

Aggressive

Friendly

Playfulness

Silent

Very Playful

Friendliness

Not Friendly

Super Friendly

Compatibility with other dogs

Aggressive

Friendly

Need for attention

Independent

Very Needy

Barking

Quiet

Loud

Temperament with Kids

Aggressive

Friendly

Playfulness

Silent

Very Playful

Friendliness

Not Friendly

Super Friendly

Compatibility with other dogs

Aggressive

Friendly

Need for attention

Independent

Very Needy

Basic Information

Avg Monthly Expenses

₹ 3,550

Basic

₹ 5,400

Premium

Life Expectancy

12 - 15 years

Size

Medium

Group

Herding

Suitable Climate

10º - 25º celsius

Ideal Space

House with backyard

Exercise Required

60 - 120 minutes a day

Shedding Level

Moderate Shedding

Cost to buy

₹ 20,000 - ₹ 50,000

Avg Monthly Expenses

₹ 4,650

Basic

₹ 6,600

Premium

Life Expectancy

12 - 15 years

Size

Medium

Group

Sporting

Suitable Climate

10º - 30º celsius

Ideal Space

House with backyard

Exercise Required

60 - 90 minutes a day

Shedding Level

Moderate Shedding

Cost to buy

₹ 20,000 - ₹ 60,000

Overall Summary

Pros

  • Excellent herding instincts.

  • Energetic and playful.

  • Versatile working dog.

Cons

  • Requires significant exercise.

  • Can be prone to boredom.

  • Moderate barking tendencies.

Pros

  • Enthusiastic and cheerful.

  • Distinctive and attractive coat.

  • Ideal for active households.

Cons

  • Prone to separation anxiety.

  • Strong prey drive.

  • Not suited for very hot climates.

Frequently Asked Questions

How can I avoid common health problems like hip dysplasia and PRA in my Working Kelpie dogs?

Select a good breeder who places importance on hip scoring and eye clearances for breeding stock. Keep your Kelpie lean, increase fitness level gradually, and prevent repetitive high-impact jumping during puppyhood. Regular check-ups with your vet and early detection of eye problems catch them before they become severe.

What foods are my Working Kelpie pups not allowed to eat?

Avoid chocolate, grapes, raisins, onions, garlic, leeks, xylitol, alcohol, and caffeine, as well as extremely high-fat scraps. They may produce toxic reactions, anemia, gastrointestinal problems, kidney failure, or pancreatitis. Keep human foods out of reach and use only vet-approved diets and treats.

Is a Working Kelpie able to survive on a raw food (BARF) diet?

Yes, a few Kelpies thrive on well-formulated raw diets—but sound planning is essential. A BARF diet usually consists of raw meat, meaty bones, organs, and some produce. Have a veterinarian or board-certified animal nutritionist advise on complete and balanced dietary needs for your dog's life stage and workload.

What amount of exercise does a Working Kelpie require each day?

Expect 1.5–3 hours total physical and mental stimulation daily, adjusted to age and fitness. Cycle the organized runs, herding-type games, obedience, agility, scent work, and puzzle activities. Lacking sufficient outlets, boredom can result in digging, chewing, and high-energy naughtiness.